Textual issues : Matching the electronic text to base text

Chinese Text Project

Discussion -> Textual issues -> Matching the electronic text to base text

This thread relates to:

《逸周書·文傳解》 #1

2013-11-06 21:00:04Matching the electronic text to base text
Posted by: egrebnev	Sorry, it took me a while to realise that the scanned text actually follows Zhu Youceng's edition, and not the Sibu congkan edition, which should be the base text. Zhu Youceng's edition is full of emendations from leishu, and this chapter contains quite a lot of them. Therefore, if we want to make it closer to Sibu congkan edition, we should replace the whole block in the beginning: 召太子發曰：「嗚呼！我身老矣！吾語汝，我所保與我所守，傳之子孫。吾厚德而廣惠，忠信而志愛。人君之行，不為驕侈，不為泰靡，不淫于美，括柱茅茨，為民愛費。山林非時不升斤斧，以成草木之長川；澤非時不入網罟，以成魚鱉之長；不卵不䠣，以成鳥獸之長；畋獵唯時，不殺童羊，不天胎童牛，不服童馬，不馳不騖澤，不行害，土不失其宜，萬物不失其性，天下不失其時。 with: 太子發曰：「吾語汝，所保所守，守之哉！厚德廣惠，忠信愛人君子之行，不為驕侈，不為靡泰，不淫于美，括柱茅茨，為愛費。山林非時不升斤斧，以成草木之長；川澤非時不入網罟，以成魚鱉之長；不麛不卵，以成鳥獸之長；畋渔以時，童不夭胎，馬不馳騖，土不失宜。

2013-11-06 21:00:04Matching the electronic text to base text

Posted by: egrebnev

Sorry, it took me a while to realise that the scanned text actually follows Zhu Youceng's edition, and not the Sibu congkan edition, which should be the base text. Zhu Youceng's edition is full of emendations from leishu, and this chapter contains quite a lot of them. Therefore, if we want to make it closer to Sibu congkan edition, we should replace the whole block in the beginning:
召太子發曰：「嗚呼！我身老矣！吾語汝，我所保與我所守，傳之子孫。吾厚德而廣惠，忠信而志愛。人君之行，不為驕侈，不為泰靡，不淫于美，括柱茅茨，為民愛費。山林非時不升斤斧，以成草木之長川；澤非時不入網罟，以成魚鱉之長；不卵不䠣，以成鳥獸之長；畋獵唯時，不殺童羊，不天胎童牛，不服童馬，不馳不騖澤，不行害，土不失其宜，萬物不失其性，天下不失其時。
with:
太子發曰：「吾語汝，所保所守，守之哉！厚德廣惠，忠信愛人君子之行，不為驕侈，不為靡泰，不淫于美，括柱茅茨，為愛費。山林非時不升斤斧，以成草木之長；川澤非時不入網罟，以成魚鱉之長；不麛不卵，以成鳥獸之長；畋渔以時，
童不夭胎，馬不馳騖，土不失宜。

2013-11-06 21:04:18Matching the electronic text to base text
Posted by: egrebnev	In the following passage, it is probably better to replace: 土可犯，材可蓄，潤溼不穀，樹之竹葦莞蒲，礫石不可穀 with 土可犯，材可蓄，潤濕不谷，樹之竹葦莞蒲，礫石不可谷
Posted by: egrebnev

2013-11-06 21:49:50Matching the electronic text to base text
Posted by: egrebnev	故凡土地之閒者，聖人裁之，並為民利，是以魚鱉歸其淵，鳥獸歸其林，孤寡辛苦，咸賴其生，山林以遂其材，工匠以為其器，百物以平其利，商賈以通其貨，工不失其務，農不失其時，是謂和德。 should possibly be replaced with: 故凡土地之閒者，聖人裁之，並為民利，是魚鱉歸其泉，鳥歸其林，孤寡辛苦，咸賴其生，山以遂其材，工匠以為其器，百物以平其利，商賈以通其貨，工不失其務，農不失其時，是謂和德。

2013-11-06 21:49:50Matching the electronic text to base text

Posted by: egrebnev

故凡土地之閒者，聖人裁之，並為民利，是以魚鱉歸其淵，鳥獸歸其林，孤寡辛苦，咸賴其生，山林以遂其材，工匠以為其器，百物以平其利，商賈以通其貨，工不失其務，農不失其時，是謂和德。
should possibly be replaced with:
故凡土地之閒者，聖人裁之，並為民利，是魚鱉歸其泉，鳥歸其林，孤寡辛苦，咸賴其生，山以遂其材，工匠以為其器，百物以平其利，商賈以通其貨，工不失其務，農不失其時，是謂和德。

2013-11-06 21:51:02Matching the electronic text to base text
Posted by: egrebnev	弗思弗行，禍至無日矣。明開塞禁舍者，其取天下如化，不明開塞禁舍者，其失天下如化。 should probably be replaced with: 弗思弗行，至無日矣。不明開塞禁舍者，其如天下何？
Posted by: egrebnev

2013-11-06 21:51:24Matching the electronic text to base text
Posted by: egrebnev	and王之始也。 should probably be replaced with: 王始也。
Posted by: egrebnev

To participate in the discussion, please log in to your CTP account using the form below. If you don't yet have an account, click here to set one up.

Enjoy this site? Please help.

Site design and content copyright 2006-2024. When quoting or citing information from this site, please link to the corresponding page or to https://ctext.org. Please note that the use of automatic download software on this site is strictly prohibited, and that users of such software are automatically banned without warning to save bandwidth. 沪ICP备09015720号-3

Comments? Suggestions? Please raise them here.